Williams versus Capriati

 

Rating System: Matches are rated according to basic quality of play determined by the quantity of unforced errors . Other rating systems are under development. We have chosen the parameter " percentage of unforced errors" as out basic metric because of how unpleasant it is to watch matches that are filled with careless errors. After reviewing a wide selection of matches, we have decided on a nonlinear scale as follows: 0 to 14% is an exceptional level of play. Martina Hingis has played matches at this level. Hence 0-15 is denoted as exceptional. 15 to 19% is Excellent. 20-22% is very good. 23-26% is good; 27-33% is adequate; 34-40% is poor; Above 40% is very poor (there are plenty of examples).
Player  Williams  Capriati Match
Total Points Won  58  30  88
Total Errors  17  19  36
Earned Points  39  13  52
Percentage of Errors  29%  63%  41%

Who Won/Lost

 Won    
Quality of Play  Adequate  Very Poor  Very Poor
Could the loser win by just reducing their errors?      No
Could the loser win by just reducing their errors if their opponent also reduced their errors?      No